U.S. Supreme Court Considers Religious Exception to Anti-Discrimination Laws

Author: Nacht Law
Published: 2011/11/25 - Updated: 2021/06/13
Contents: Summary - Main - Related Publications

Synopsis: United States Supreme Court to decide if ministerial exception which allows religious institutions to discriminate for certain positions encompasses disability. For example, the Roman Catholic Church has been able to hire only male priests and discriminate on the basis of gender because of the ministerial exception. Currently, the ministerial exception in federal law could be used as a pretext to deny employment to someone for a variety of otherwise-prohibited reasons, including his or her race, sex, age or disability...

Main Digest

Court to decide if the ministerial exception, which allows religious institutions to discriminate for certain positions, encompasses the disabilities. Employment Discrimination, also known as workplace discrimination, is discrimination in hiring, promotion, job assignment, termination, and compensation. It includes various types of harassment.

The Supreme Court of the United States recently heard oral arguments in a case focused on the intersection of religious freedom and civil rights. A woman claiming she was prevented from continuing to teach at a religious school in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is asking the court to clarify the scope of the "ministerial exception" to employment discrimination laws.

Teacher Asked to Resign After Disability Leave

The woman was a fourth-grade teacher at a school run by the Lutheran Church - Missouri Synod where she taught secular and religious classes and led student prayers. The school made her a "called" teacher, deeming her religiously fit for a permanent teaching position at the school and a commissioned minister, reports the Huffington Post.

A few years later the teacher went on disability leave for a sleep disorder, and when she returned, the school asked her to resign. The teacher then threatened to file an employment-discrimination lawsuit with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), alleging that the church violated the ADA. In response, the school fired her based on church teachings that prohibit Lutheran leaders from suing the church. Instead, they are directed to resolve their disputes within the church structure.

The Ministerial Exception to Employment Discrimination Laws

Over several decades, the ministerial exception to employment discrimination laws has been developed by American courts. It essentially states that the First Amendment's separation of church and state prevents courts from enforcing anti-discrimination employment laws on behalf of employees of religious organizations. Because it is a Constitutional prohibition, the exception generally applies to state discrimination laws. For example, the Roman Catholic Church has been able to hire only male priests and discriminate on the basis of gender because of the ministerial exception. The basic principle behind it is that the government should not intervene in religious organizations' employment decisions regarding their leaders

However, the teacher in the Supreme Court case asserts that the ministerial exception should not apply to leaders with primarily secular responsibilities such as teaching elementary school, in contrast to clergy. In fact, that is very similar to the approach taken by Michigan courts last year when ruling on the ministerial exception to Michigan anti-discrimination laws. In a 2010 Michigan case, the state appeals court followed a multi-factor test to find a ministerial exception meant the Michigan Whistle-blower Protection Act couldn't help a teacher because her teaching duties were "primarily religious."

Currently, the ministerial exception in federal law could be used as a pretext to deny employment to someone for a variety of otherwise-prohibited reasons, including his or her race, sex, age or disability, regardless of the job duties ruling on whether or when a religious organization can be sued by an employee for employment discrimination is expected in the spring of 2012.

Attribution/Source(s):

This quality-reviewed publication pertaining to our Disability Discrimination section was selected for circulation by the editors of Disabled World due to its likely interest to our disability community readers. Though the content may have been edited for style, clarity, or length, the article "U.S. Supreme Court Considers Religious Exception to Anti-Discrimination Laws" was originally written by Nacht Law, and submitted for publishing on 2011/11/25 (Edit Update: 2021/06/13). Should you require further information or clarification, Nacht Law can be contacted at the nachtlaw.com website. Disabled World makes no warranties or representations in connection therewith.

📢 Discover Related Topics


👍 Share This Information To:
𝕏.com Facebook Reddit

Page Information, Citing and Disclaimer

Disabled World is an independent disability community founded in 2004 to provide disability news and information to people with disabilities, seniors, their family and/or carers. You can connect with us on social media such as X.com and our Facebook page.

Cite This Page (APA): Nacht Law. (2011, November 25). U.S. Supreme Court Considers Religious Exception to Anti-Discrimination Laws. Disabled World. Retrieved April 16, 2024 from www.disabled-world.com/disability/discrimination/religious-exception.php

Permalink: <a href="https://www.disabled-world.com/disability/discrimination/religious-exception.php">U.S. Supreme Court Considers Religious Exception to Anti-Discrimination Laws</a>: United States Supreme Court to decide if ministerial exception which allows religious institutions to discriminate for certain positions encompasses disability.

Disabled World provides general information only. Materials presented are never meant to substitute for qualified professional medical care. Any 3rd party offering or advertising does not constitute an endorsement.