Which is Better, Real Sugar or Sugar Substitutes?

Fitness and Nutrition

Author: Thomas C. Weiss
Published: 2015/09/10 - Updated: 2023/05/31
Contents: Summary - Definition - Introduction - Main - Related

Synopsis: Information regarding natural and artificial sweeteners as diabetic substitutes for sugar consumption. Most artificially sweetened foods still have calories and carbohydrates, so it is essential to fit them into your daily carbohydrate, and calorie counts like any other food or drink product. The FDA regulates sugar substitutes as 'food additives.' They must be reviewed and approved by the FDA before being presented for sale in America.


A sugar substitute is a food additive that provides a sweet taste like sugar while containing significantly less food energy. Some sugar substitutes are natural, and some are synthetic. Those that are not natural are, in general, called artificial sweeteners.

Main Digest

People with diabetes often have questions concerning sugar substitutes. The subject is polarizing; some people love sugar substitutes while others cannot stand them. Some people with diabetes are concerned about their safety, and some want tips about using them more. For several people with diabetes, sugar substitutes, which include both natural and artificial sweeteners, provide solutions for removing excess carbohydrates and calories while still retaining the ability to enjoy sweets.

Sugar substitutes are among the world's most scientifically tested food products. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has stated sugar substitutes are 'generally recognized as safe.'

The one sweetener that still has a warning on its labels is 'aspartame,' which is the sweetener in NutraSweet and Equal Classic. The reason is that a small population of people, approximately 1 in 25,000 in America, have a genetic condition that prevents the metabolization of 'phenylalanine,' amino acid in aspartame.

Even though there remains a great amount of testing to be performed as new products are offered, much more is now known about sugar substitutes than when the first one, saccharin, was discovered more than a century ago.

Which is Better, Real Sugar or Sugar Substitutes?

The answer to this question is, 'it depends.' Both may fit into a healthy eating plan, yet you should limit sugar and sugar substitute intake.

Where heart health is concerned, short-term studies suggest diet soda is better than regular soda. A study in Denmark discovered that healthy people who drank around four cups a day of sugar-sweetened cola over six months experienced significant increases in belly fat, triglycerides, and cholesterol compared with those who drank aspartame-sweetened cola.

Most artificially sweetened foods still have calories and carbohydrates, so it is important to fit them into your daily carbohydrate and calorie counts like any other food or drink product.

Sugar Substitutes and Cancer

According to Kantha Shelke, Ph.D., the idea of sugar substitutes causing cancer came up when early studies revealed that high doses of the sweetener 'cyclamate,' which is banned from food products in America, combined with saccharin, caused bladder cancer in laboratory animals.

Doctor Shelke made this statement while working for Corvus Blue LLC, a food science and research firm in Chicago. The FDA has since deemed sugar substitutes used in America to be safe based upon extensive animal and human studies.

In addition, studies have not documented negative effects related to the intake of sugar substitutes, even when people have consumed fairly large amounts. Only a few studies have been done on people to evaluate the long-term effects of using sugar substitutes.

The FDA has set acceptable daily intake limits for each sugar substitute. One study showed that the average daily intake of the heaviest users of aspartame was only 5-10% of the average daily intake limitation.

Sugar Substitutes and Baking

At the 'Better Homes and Gardens Test Kitchen,' recipes were tested using regular granulated or brown sugar.

Upon achieving the results using these sugars, the Kitchen tested several sugar substitutes. They had the most success with baking blends such as C& H Light or Splenda Sugar Blend and limited success with other brands depending on the length of baking or cooking time.

Splenda Granular was used successfully in several recipes, and the Kitchen had some success using Equal, Sweet'N Low, and Truvia.

Sugar Substitutes and Potential Health Concerns

Sugar substitutes have been under intense scrutiny for decades.

Critics of sugar substitutes believe they cause several health issues, including cancer. The reason is largely due to studies dating back to the 1970s that linked saccharin to bladder cancer in laboratory rats. Because of the studies, saccharin once carried a warning label that it might be hazardous to a person's health.

Yet, according to the National Cancer Institute and other health agencies, no solid scientific evidence exists that any sugar substitutes approved for use in America cause cancer or other serious health issues.

Many research studies confirm that sugar substitutes are generally safe in limited quantities, even for pregnant women. Due to the results of newer studies, the warning label on saccharin was ended. The FDA regulates sugar substitutes as 'food additives.' The FDA must review and approve them before being presented for sale in America.

In some instances, the FDA declares a sugar substitute to be 'generally recognized as safe (GRAS).' GRAS substances, including highly refined Stevia, are deemed by qualified professionals based on scientific information as being safe for the use they are intended for, or they have such a long history of common use in foods that they are considered generally safe and do not require FDA approval before sale.

The FDA has also established an acceptable daily intake (ADI) for every sugar substitute. The ADI is the maximum amount considered safe to consume daily throughout a person's lifetime. ADIs are intended to be around 100 times less than the smallest amount that may cause health concerns.

Sugar Substitutes and Moderate Use

When choosing sugar substitutes, it is important to be an educated consumer. Become informed while looking beyond the hype. Even though sugar substitutes might help manage a person's weight, they certainly are not a 'magic bullet' and need to be used in moderation. If you use sugar substitutes to save on calories, be careful not to consume higher-calorie foods to reward your saved calories.

Simply because a food is sold as 'sugar-free' does not mean it is free of calories. If you consume too many sugar-free foods, you may still gain weight if they contain other ingredients containing calories. Remember that processed foods, which often contain sugar substitutes, usually do not offer the same health benefits as whole foods such as vegetables and fruits.

Resources That Provide Relevant Information

Author Credentials:

Thomas C. Weiss is a researcher and editor for Disabled World. Thomas attended college and university courses earning a Masters, Bachelors and two Associate degrees, as well as pursing Disability Studies. As a Nursing Assistant Thomas has assisted people from a variety of racial, religious, gender, class, and age groups by providing care for people with all forms of disabilities from Multiple Sclerosis to Parkinson's; para and quadriplegia to Spina Bifida. Explore Thomas' complete biography for comprehensive insights into his background, expertise, and accomplishments.

Related Publications

Share This Information To:
𝕏.com Facebook Reddit

Page Information, Citing and Disclaimer

Disabled World is an independent disability community founded in 2004 to provide news and information to people with disabilities, seniors, their family and carers. We'd love for you to follow and connect with us on social media!

Cite This Page (APA): Weiss, T. C. (2015, September 10 - Last revised: 2023, May 31). Which is Better, Real Sugar or Sugar Substitutes?. Disabled World. Retrieved July 17, 2024 from www.disabled-world.com/fitness/substitutes.php

Permalink: <a href="https://www.disabled-world.com/fitness/substitutes.php">Which is Better, Real Sugar or Sugar Substitutes?</a>: Information regarding natural and artificial sweeteners as diabetic substitutes for sugar consumption.

Disabled World provides general information only. Materials presented are never meant to substitute for qualified medical care. Any 3rd party offering or advertising does not constitute an endorsement.