Six Feet Not Far Enough Apart for COVID-19 Social Distancing
Author: Disabled World : Contact: www.disabled-world.com
Published: 2020-04-06 : (Rev. 2020-05-16)
Article looks at examples of why social distancing should be a far greater distance than the recommended six feet currently advocated.
- If an oncoming hiker coughs just before you pass, you're probably walking through a cloud of viruses that stay suspended in air...
- A study found under the right conditions, liquid droplets from sneezes, coughs and just exhaling can travel more than 26 feet - and linger in the air for minutes.
Studies, coupled with the high number of potentially asymptomatic people, has prompted the U.S. CDC to recommend that all Americans wear cloth masks in public. "There are micro-droplets and they can stay in the air for a while," said Dr. Scott Miscovich, with Hawaii's coronavirus task force.
Global experts in aerosol science are also sounding the alarm that current guidelines and regulations, which include the six-foot rule, may not be enough to keep people safe in public settings. Lydia Bourouiba, a Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) professor, contends that those recommendations may need to pushed another 20-plus feet.
A new study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) found that even the simple act of talking can produce hundreds of tiny droplets that have the potential to carry viruses and can remain in the air from 8 -14 minutes - (https://www.pnas.org/content/early/2020/05/12/2006874117).
Richard Corsi, a Portland State University dean, has also studied the spread of COVID-19 through both large and tiny droplets in the air and recommends people stay 20 feet away from each other when they’re outdoors. If an oncoming hiker coughs just before you pass, "you're probably walking through a cloud of viruses that stay suspended in air," Corsi said.
Germs that carry viruses can travel much farther by simply breathing or talking. And, if wind is blowing it can travel even greater distances and blow right to you. In addition, pathogens in, for example a sneeze cloud, could potentially reach air circulation systems inside buildings. There has been sampling done in air vents with positive detection of the virus.
"Aerosols - (micron-size droplets) - are different," says Dr. Stanley Deresinski, clinical professor of medicine and infectious diseases at Stanford University. "Very small particles may be suspended in the air for a long time, sometimes for hours. They're suspended by air currents."
A study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association found that under the right conditions, liquid droplets from sneezes, coughs and just exhaling can travel more than 26 feet - and linger in the air for minutes.
Cartoon figures of a man and woman holding a sign that says Stay at Home.
Hypothetical Examples of 6 Feet Rule Not Being Far Enough
- 1 - Imagine you are out walking and staying six feet from a person, or persons, walking in front of you. It is quite easy to see that should a person in front of you be smoking and exhales, that you are breathing in that exhaled smoke within a second or two as you move into the space the person has just vacated. The faster people are walking, the quicker you will be breathing in their exhaled air.
- 2 - Now, imagine if you are a bicycle rider following another rider on a bike track. Within a fraction of a second you will have inhaled the air that was just exhaled a split second ago from their lungs!
- 3 - While you are out walking and a car passes - the car obviously disturbs the air around it - causing eddies and currents of air to wash over you, you are now covered in the air that walkers around you have breathed out - as they also are breathing your exhaled air...
The World Health Organization (WHO) say they have reviewed reports about transmission, and say more peer-reviewed tests are needed before they change their social distancing guidelines.
The only sure way to prevent yourself from getting infected by COVID-19 is by staying indoors and away from other people. Go out only as needed for essential trips to collect food and medicine, or brief exercise.
- 1 - Six Feet Not Far Enough Apart for COVID-19 Social Distancing : Disabled World (2020/04/06)
- 2 - Largest Analysis Reveals Risk Factors for COVID-19 Death : Oxford University (2020/05/09)
- 3 - COVID-19 Novel Coronavirus Information : Disabled World (2020/01/29)
- 4 - COVID-19: Just 1 Infected Person Could Trigger Round 2 : Disabled World (2020/04/12)
- 5 - How Will the COVID-19 Coronavirus Outbreak End? : Disabled World (2020/03/11)
- 6 - COVIDView: CDC's Weekly COVID-19 Surveillance Report : U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2020/04/05)
- 7 - U.S. Medicare and Telehealth Services During COVID-19 Pandemic : Disabled World (2020/03/22)
• Disabled World is strictly a news and information website provided for general informational purpose only and does not constitute medical advice. Materials presented are in no way meant to be a substitute for professional medical care by a qualified practitioner, nor should they be construed as such. Any 3rd party offering or advertising on disabled-world.com does not constitute endorsement by Disabled World.
• Please report outdated or inaccurate information to us.