Patient Complaints - Doctors Fail to Disclose Risks
Published : 2011-09-20
Author : University of Melbourne
Synopsis* : Allegations was that doctors most often surgeons fail to mention or properly explain risks of surgery complications.
Main DigestIn more than 70 per cent of legal disputes over informed consent, patients allege the doctor failed to properly explain the risks of complications, a University of Melbourne study published in the latest Medical Journal of Australia has found.
Professor David Studdert from the Melbourne School of Population Health and Melbourne Law School and co-authors reviewed nearly 2000 negligence claims against doctors insured by Avant Mutual Group Limited and complaints lodged with the Health Services Commissioner of Victoria between January 2002 and December 2008.
The authors found that in 71 per cent of these cases the primary allegation was that the doctor, most often a surgeon, failed to mention or properly explain risks of complications.
"This is the first study to investigate in a real-world setting what happens when informed consent goes poorly from the patient's perspective," Professor Studdert said.
More than 92 per cent of cases involved surgical procedures and 16 per cent involved cosmetic procedures. Patients' concerns about problems in the informed consent process sat alongside concerns about other aspects of care in about half the cases.
Five treatment types accounted for almost 50 per cent of the total cases. These were surgical procedures on reproductive organs, the face, breast, eyes and side effects of prescription medications.
Plastic surgeons experienced complaint rates that were more than twice those of any other specialty or sub-specialty group.
Lead author, neurosurgical registrar Dr Andrew Gogos, said the problem was communication. "In my experience, most doctors feel that they adequately discuss the risks of a procedure as part of their practice. Our findings show that our patients do not always share this view."
"The typical dispute over informed consent involves an operation and relates to the adequacy of explanations about risks of a particular complication. The complication may be anything from the risk of infection, pain or scarring, paralysis, even death." Dr Gogos said.
"With cosmetic surgery, patients are typically healthy going into the procedure and their expectations of a positive outcome tend to be very high. This causes them to worry about even small risks.
Professor Studdert said improved understanding of these situations would help to spotlight areas of care in which there is a gap between what doctors talk about and what patients want to hear.
"With Australian courts now looking to patient preferences for setting legal standards for medical risk disclosure, studies of medico-legal disputes can provide valuable insights."
"Much more can be learned about how to improve medical care from close analysis of disputes over preventable events," he said.
You're reading Disabled World. Be sure to check out our homepage for further informative disability news, reviews, disability sports events, exclusive stories and how-tos. You can also find us on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn.
Related Cosmetic Surgery Documents
- 1: Benefits of Mommy Makeover Cosmetic Surgery : The biggest benefit of a mommy makeover is the change it can produce in a woman's life and in her opinion of herself.
- 2: Those Traveling Abroad for Plastic Surgery Can Bring Home Serious Complications : Initial medical tourism surgery may be cheap, but can place significant burden on US public health systems when patients return from abroad with complications.
- 3: Breast Reconstruction After Mastectomy : Breast reconstruction is intended to restore your breast to its original size and shape so that your breasts look symmetrical in a bra or clothing.
- 4: Breast Implants After Breast Cancer : Women report breast reconstruction was an important factor in helping them to recover psychologically from the devastating effects of breast cancer.
- 5: Design Your Own Breasts Before Augmentation Surgery : SculptMyDream incorporates an extensive library of 3D photographs of women that have had breast augmentation surgery.
*Disclaimer: Disabled World provides general information only. Materials presented are in no way meant to be a substitute for professional medical care by a qualified practitioner, nor should they be construed as such. Any 3rd party offering or advertising on disabled-world.com does not constitute endorsement by Disabled World. View our Advertising Policy for further information. Please report outdated or inaccurate information to us.
Journal: Disabled World. Language: English (U.S.). Author: University of Melbourne. Electronic Publication Date: 2011-09-20. Title: Patient Complaints - Doctors Fail to Disclose Risks, Source: <a href=https://www.disabled-world.com/medical/surgery/cosmetic/disclosing-risks.php>Patient Complaints - Doctors Fail to Disclose Risks</a>. Retrieved 2021-04-16, from https://www.disabled-world.com/medical/surgery/cosmetic/disclosing-risks.php - Reference: DW#459-8464.