Skip to main content

Harris v. Quinn Decision - US Supreme Court Delivers Major Blow to Government Unions

  • Synopsis: Published: 2014-06-30 - Ruling states state governments cannot force-unionize participants in state entitlement programs or force them to pay union dues as a condition of receiving help from the state. For further information pertaining to this article contact: Illinois Policy Institute at www.illinoispolicy.org.

Main Document

Quote: "The 5-4 decision was in favor of the plaintiff Pam Harris, a mother from suburban Chicago who takes care of her disabled son and participates in a state Medicaid program."

The U.S. Supreme Court has issued a groundbreaking ruling on the case Harris v. Quinn. The Court's ruling states that state governments cannot force-unionize participants in state entitlement programs or force them to pay union dues as a condition of receiving help from the state.

In 2009, Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn issued an executive order that said a group of Illinois residents who participate in a state Medicaid program for the developmentally disabled would be considered state workers for the sole purpose of unionization. Government unions would then be able to force participants in this program to pay union dues as a condition of receiving help from the state.

The 5-4 decision was in favor of the plaintiff Pam Harris, a mother from suburban Chicago who takes care of her disabled son and participates in a state Medicaid program. The justices ruled that Medicaid beneficiaries and people participating in state entitlement programs are not state employees, and cannot be forced into a union or forced to pay union dues.

The Illinois Policy Institute's Director of Labor Policy, Paul Kersey, issued the following statement on today's ruling:

"Today's decision delivers a major blow to the public employee unions in Illinois and nationally, and is good news to people like suburban Chicago mom Pam Harris.

For more than a decade, government unions have been forcing people who are not state workers - moms and dads caring for children with developmental disabilities, home daycare providers for low income children and others - to pay dues to a union as a condition of receiving help from their state governments. In Illinois, both Gov. Pat Quinn and now-disgraced former Gov. Rod Blagojevich issued executive orders allowing the unionization of people who were not state workers. This resulted in government unions making $20 million a year from these workers, many of whom never wanted to join or pay dues to a union in the first place.

But fortunately, today's ruling strikes down those executive orders. Today, the U.S. Supreme Court has affirmed that plaintiff Pam Harris - a suburban Chicago mother trying to care for her disabled son - will not have to jeopardize and limit his care by being forced to join a union she does not want, agree with or support.

"The attempts by Quinn and Blagojevich to unionize Medicaid recipients were motivated by greed and politics, not by an interest in helping Illinois families. Luckily, the Supreme Court has ruled in favor of the families in Illinois and nationwide who are fighting to take care of their loved ones."

The Illinois Policy Institute is a nonpartisan research and education organization dedicated to making Illinois a beacon for liberty and prosperity for all citizens. As a leading voice for economic liberty and government accountability, the Institute engages policy makers, opinion leaders and citizens on the state and local level by promoting free market principles and liberty-based public policy initiatives for a better Illinois. To learn more about the Institute or review policy briefs, please visit: www.illinoispolicy.org



Information from our Disability News: Illinois section - (Full List).

E-Newsletter

Loan Information for low income singles, families, seniors and disabled. Includes home, vehicle and personal loans.


Famous People with Disabilities - Well known people with disabilities and conditions who contributed to society.


List of awareness ribbon colors and their meaning. Also see our calendar of awareness dates.


Blood Pressure Chart - What should your blood pressure be. Also see information on blood group types and compatibility.


  1. New Details on Aged Brain, Alzheimer's and Dementia Revealed
  2. FDA Issues Guidance on Generic Abuse-Deterrent Opioid Development
  3. Getting a Job with a Disability - Infographic with Transcript
  4. New Sports and Disciplines for Paris 2024 Paralympics




Citation