Skip to main content
Accessibility  |  About  |  Contact  |  Privacy  |  Terms

Workers Compensation Disability - When Does Retirement Begin

  • Published: 2011-07-25 : Dugan & Associates, P.C..
  • Synopsis: If someone is receiving workers compensation disability then how does one decide if they have retired.

Main Document

Two recent Pennsylvania Supreme Court cases clarified when a worker who receives workers compensation disability payments is considered retired.

In Pennsylvania, the Supreme Court has been asked to clarify questions surrounding if someone is receiving workers compensation disability, then how does one decide if they have retired.

Two recent cases from a divided, en banc panel of the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania have addressed this question. The answer from that court is, it depends. The majority of the divided court arrived at a "totality of the circumstances" test. One of the cases, Day, v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board will be appealed to the Supreme Court, so even the answer "it depends" may depend on whether or not the Supreme Court agrees with the Commonwealth Courts reasoning.

Day v. WCAB:

Melvin Day was a Pittsburgh garbage collector until he was injured on the job in 1992. After surgery, he returned to work, but could not continue, and was assigned modified, light-duty work by 1996. He was laid off by 2001. According to the court, after his unemployment compensation ran out, he began collecting his Social Security pension and total disability workers compensation benefits. By 2007, his employer sought to suspend his benefits, claiming he had retired and "voluntarily withdrawn from the workforce."

The Workers' Compensation Judge and the Workers' Compensation Appeal Board (WCAB) agreed, and Day appeal to the Commonwealth Court. That court, examining the various Supreme Court precedents on the topic, came up with a ruling that agreed with WACB, and decided that courts must review the totality of the circumstances to determine when an injured employee has retired.

How an Employer can Terminate Workers' Compensation Benefits:

The court noted that generally, in order to suspend a claimant's WC benefits, an employer must meet the following requirements:

The employer who seeks to modify a claimant's benefits on the basis that he has recovered some or all of his ability must first produce medical evidence of a change in condition.

The employer must then produce evidence of a referral (or referrals) to a then open job (or jobs), which fits in the occupational category for which the claimant has been given medical clearance, e.g., light work, sedentary work, etc.

The claimant must then demonstrate that he has in good faith followed through on the job referral(s).

If the referral fails to result in a job then claimant's benefits should continue.

If the claimant voluntarily removes himself from the workforce, by retiring, and employer no longer needs to prove the availability of any jobs for the claimant. The court then goes to say:

"Under Henderson and its progeny, the Employer still bears the burden of showing that the claimant is no longer suffering from a loss of earning power due to his work-related injury."

The court goes on to indicate there is no specific facts or elements that need to be shown, "but by showing by the totality of the circumstances, that the claimant has chosen not to return to the workforce." Once they have done this, the burden shifts back to the claimant to show they have not "voluntarily withdrawn from the workforce."

Totality of the Circumstance:

This test is often used by courts when they cannot identify any straightforward means of arriving at a decision. Its disadvantage is that the answer may not be obvious or easy to obtain, because each case will have a somewhat different circumstance, and therefore litigation is almost always necessary to determine what the "totality" is. This is opposed to a "Bright Line Test" where it is typically easy to determine an answer.

Day's attorney is appealing because he feels the Commonwealth Court "misconstrued" the record by stating that his client began collecting a pension and Social Security. Those benefits, he said were related to his disability status. The question may turn on how detailed the record is regarding the benefits Mr. Day received. Whatever the decision, it will control how courts answer the question of when is someone retired for workers' compensation disability benefits.

Article provided by Dugan & Associates, P.C. - Visit us at

Similar Topics

1 : Unexpected Costs, Health Issues and Higher Taxes Are Biggest Retirement Surprises : CIBC.
2 : Americans with Disabilities Financially Insecure and Their Caregivers Unprepared for Retirement : The American College.
3 : Retirement Survey Shows Medicare Can Take 30 - 50% of Your Social Security Benefit : The Senior Citizens League.
4 : Best Senior Living Communities in America :
5 : Hopes, Fears and Reality of Retirement : MassMutual Retirement Services.
From our Retirement Planning section - Full List (24 Items)

Submit disability news, coming events, as well as assistive technology product news and reviews.

Loan Information for low income singles, families, seniors and disabled. Includes home, vehicle and personal loans.

Famous People with Disabilities - Well known people with disabilities and conditions who contributed to society.

List of awareness ribbon colors and their meaning. Also see our calendar of awareness dates.

Blood Pressure Chart - What should your blood pressure be, and information on blood group types/compatibility.

1 : Protein Levels in Spinal Fluid Correlate to Posture and Gait Difficulty in Parkinson's Disease
2 : Palliative Care Findings on Caregiver Depression, LGBT Partners, Moral Distress
3 : Circulation Journal's Go Red for Women Issue Focuses on Female Heart Health
4 : Wearable Stretchable Electronics Aid Stroke Recovery Treatment


Disclaimer: This site does not employ and is not overseen by medical professionals. Content on Disabled World is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of a physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. See our Terms of Service for more information.

Reporting Errors: Disabled World is an independent website, your assistance in reporting outdated or inaccurate information is appreciated. If you find an error please let us know.