If Senior CPI Used to Calculate 2017 COLA, Benefits Would Be 2.1% Higher
Author: The Senior Citizens League : Contact: seniorsleague.org
Synopsis and Key Points:
Data confirms if the government used Consumer Price Index for the Elderly to calculate COLA for 2017 instead of the index currently used, Social Security benefits would be 2.1 percent higher.
Social Security recipients would get a cost-of-living- adjustment (COLA) that's seven times higher this year if the annual boost were tied to the rise in the "seniors'" consumer price index, according to a new analysis by The Senior Citizens League (TSCL).
Recent data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor statistics confirms that had the government used the Consumer Price Index for the Elderly (CPI-E) to calculate the annual cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) for 2017 instead of the index currently used, Social Security benefits would be 2.1% higher this year instead of the tiny 0.3% that is being paid. "That means that retirees with average benefits would be getting a boost of about $28 or $29 per month instead of $4 or $5," says TSCL Social Security policy analyst Mary Johnson.
After getting no COLA at all in 2016, Social Security beneficiaries got a small cost-of-living adjustment COLA this year of 0.3%, the lowest ever paid. But few beneficiaries will see any difference. Rising Medicare costs, which are automatically deducted from the benefits of most people, completely offset the tiny increase.
Under current law, the annual boost in benefits, which is provided to keep up with inflation, is based on the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W).
That index measures cost changes in items typically used by younger working adults. It gives greater weight to costs like like gasoline, which has gone down in price in recent years, but doesn't give as much weight to medical costs and housing which have been rising rapidly and form a bigger share of spending for people age 62 and over.
"The difference between the CPI-E and the CPI-W is at its highest level since the experimental CPI-E was started in 1984," Johnson explains. "That difference is driven by steeply rising medical and housing costs which aren't reflected in the COLA that older Americans get," she says.
The 2.1% increase in the CPI-E is the combined rise in that index since the last time a COLA was payable in 2014. "But according to CPI-E data, the seniors' index would have paid a COLA of 0.6% last year, when beneficiaries got nothing at all, and another 1.5% in 2017," Johnson explains.
A switch to a more appropriate index like the CPI-E to calculate the annual COLA could have a big impact on the adequacy of Social Security benefits over a 20 to 30 year retirement, projections for TSCL indicate.
According to a new projection by Johnson, people who retired in 2015 with average benefits of $1,355 would receive about $29,568 more in Social Security income over a twenty - five year period using the CPI-E. The difference compounds over time. By the end of the 25 - year period, Johnson estimates that monthly benefits would be 8.9% higher using the CPI-E. "And this is normally the time when retirees need it the most," she says. "Financial resources are at their lowest and healthcare costs are at their highest," Johnson adds.
|How COLAs Calculated Using the CPI-E Compare With the Actual COLA|
|Year||Actual COLA||COLA Using CPI-E|
In most, but not all years the CPI-E would provide a modestly higher COLA. *Indicates year in which CPI-E was lower than CPI-W.
According to a recent TSCL survey, 80 percent of older Americans support switching to the CPI-E to calculate COLAs. TSCL is lobbying for legislation that would provide a more fair COLA by tying the calculation to a seniors index like the CPI-E. To learn more and participate in TSCL surveys, visit www.SeniorsLeague.org
- 1 - Nearly 50% of Seniors Go Without Essentials During Pandemic : The Senior Citizens League (2020/07/22)
- 2 - Understanding Ageism Discrimination : Umea University (2016/02/29)
- 3 - Senior Americans Deserve Fairer COLA Payments : The Senior Citizens League (2016/10/19)
- 4 - New Year Resolutions for Grandparents : Disabled World (2009/01/02)
- 5 - Things Seniors Can No Longer Manage to Do : John T Jones, Ph.D. (2009/03/23)
- 6 - Older Americans and the Recession Crisis : University of Michigan (2009/09/17)
- 7 - Educating Elderly Regarding Prevention of Falling : Balanced for Life Program (2010/09/24)
• Disabled World is strictly a news and information website provided for general informational purpose only and does not constitute medical advice. Materials presented are in no way meant to be a substitute for professional medical care by a qualified practitioner, nor should they be construed as such. Any 3rd party offering or advertising on disabled-world.com does not constitute endorsement by Disabled World.
• Please report outdated or inaccurate information to us.