Medical Device Firms Paid UK Health Bodies Over 37 Million
Author: University of Bath
Published: 18 Apr 2024 - Updated: 8 Nov 2026
Publication Details: Peer-Reviewed | Observational Study
Table of Contents:
Synopsis - Definition - Overview - FAQs - Insights, Updates - Related Content
Synopsis
This research, published in the peer-reviewed journal Health Policy and Technology by researchers from the University of Bath and RCSI University of Medicine and Health Sciences in Dublin, examined education payments from medical device companies reported in 53 countries between 2017 and 2019. It found about 425 million euros in such payments overall, with UK hospitals, universities and other health organizations receiving more than 37 million euros, placing the UK third behind Switzerland and Spain. The authors warn that these payments create a conflict of interest, and that the true amounts are likely far higher because companies report only voluntarily to an industry-run database. The findings matter to patients who receive implants such as pacemakers or joint replacements, and to policymakers weighing mandatory disclosure, because choices about which devices are used should rest on patient benefit alone.*
At a Glance
- 1 - Payments were reported to a database run by the trade body MedTech Europe.
- 2 - The largest UK recipients included Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust.
- 3 - Johnson and Johnson Medical, Abbott Laboratories and Boston Scientific were the top three payers.
- 4 - The pharmaceutical industry reported about 2.96 billion euros in payments, showing how much less device makers disclose.
Topic Definition
- Conflict of Interest in Healthcare
A conflict of interest in healthcare is a situation in which a doctor, hospital, researcher or other provider has financial or personal ties, such as payments, grants, gifts or consulting fees from a company, that could influence their professional decisions about patient care, research or teaching. Conflicts of interest do not prove wrongdoing, but because they can bias choices about treatments and devices, they are usually managed through disclosure rules, independent review and limits on industry payments.
Overview
Joint replacements, pacemakers, surgical instruments, and sutures; medical devices are a staple of healthcare. New research published in the journal Health Policy and Technology reveals that UK hospitals, universities, and other healthcare organizations received over €37 million in 'education' payments from the medical device firms that supply them, sparking concerns by the report authors that a "worrying conflict of interest" is at play.
The most high-profile conflict of interest case in recent years in the UK surrounding medical devices has been vaginal mesh implants.
The report also highlights major transparency shortcomings. The recorded payments detailed in the report are expected to be just the tip of the iceberg of cash flowing between healthcare providers and medical device companies such as Johnson & Johnson Medical, Abbott Laboratories, and Boston Scientific. This is because it is not a statutory requirement for medical companies to disclose payments.
The authors are urging the UK government and EU governments to implement a recommendation from Baroness Cumberlege's 2020 independent review, First Do No Harm, which recommended that manufacturers be required to disclose any financial payments and benefits in kind they offer to healthcare professionals and providers.
Key findings from the report:
- The study estimates payments of €425 million in 'education' payments from medical device companies reported in 53 countries between 2017-2019.
- The UK was ranked as the third-highest recipient of payments behind Switzerland (nearly €178 million) and Spain (nearly €86 million).
- The largest payments to UK recipients went to Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust and The London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine.
- The top 3 companies making payments are: Johnson & Johnson Medical (over €184 million); Abbott Laboratories (over €44 million); and Boston Scientific (over €33 million).
- The payments are "education-related," meaning they should support the education of doctors and other healthcare professionals, for example through fellowships, grants, scholarships, and "educational events".
- Payments are voluntarily reported to a database run by MedTechEurope, a medical device trade body.
Dr. James Larkin, lead author from RCSI University of Medicine and Health Sciences, Dublin, said:
"This is not a trivial issue. The payments reported represent a worrying conflict of interest. We know that free lunch can influence clinical practice, so this begs the question: could these payments undermine patient care?"
Dr. Piotr Ozieranski, co-author from the Centre for the Analysis of Social Policy, University of Bath, said:
"If you are being fitted with a pacemaker, you trust the device has been chosen in the best interests of patient care, not because of a financial incentive. The stakes are high if this is undermined, as evidenced by the mesh implants scandal."
The authors also raise concerns about major transparency shortcomings of the MedTechEurope database.
Dr. Piotr Ozieranski said:
"It is impossible for patients, journalists, policymakers, and regulators to verify if a doctor or a healthcare provider has a potential conflict of interest with a medical device company because the medical device companies only disclose some of their payments. Considering the vast sums of money involved, this is a major accountability and transparency issue."
"An EU mandated system of disclosure for the medical device and pharmaceutical industries could address these shortcomings and enhance transparency in the healthcare sector's interactions with industry."
Dr. James Larkin said:
"The study is likely the tip of the iceberg on the money that's changing hands in the UK because medical device firms only seem to be disclosing a small proportion of their payments. Compare the €37 million reported by medical companies with the €2.96 billion reported by the pharmaceutical industry, which has greater transparency."
In 2009, an Institute of Medicine report said conflicts of interest "threaten the integrity of scientific investigations, the objectivity of medical education, the quality of patient care," and may also "jeopardize public trust in medicine."
University of Bath
The University of Bath is one of the UK's leading universities, with a reputation for high-impact research, excellence in education, student experience and graduate prospects. Research from Bath is helping to change the world for the better. Across the University's three Faculties and School of Management, our research is making an impact in society, leading to low-carbon living, positive digital futures, and improved health and wellbeing.
More on this topic: Europe News Publications - UK Health Care Publications - Home Medical Devices Publications
Frequently Asked Questions
NOTE: Researched FAQs by Disabled World (DW)
Do US doctors have to disclose payments from device makers?
Yes, under the Physician Payments Sunshine Act, drug and device makers must report most payments to US doctors and teaching hospitals, and the data is published in the Open Payments database.
Can patients look up payments to doctors in the UK?
The pharmaceutical industry publishes payments through the Disclosure UK database, but many doctors decline to be named and device makers are not fully covered.
What was the vaginal mesh scandal?
Thousands of women who received mesh implants to treat pelvic organ prolapse or incontinence reported serious complications such as chronic pain. The UK paused most mesh use for incontinence in 2018.
What is an education payment from industry?
It is money or support from a company for training health professionals, such as funding for conferences, fellowships, scholarships or courses. Critics say it can build loyalty to a company and its products.
How are medical devices approved in the UK?
Medical devices in the UK are regulated by the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency and need a conformity mark showing they meet safety and performance standards before use.
Can industry payments change how doctors treat patients?
Studies, mostly from the United States, have linked even small payments such as meals to higher prescribing of the sponsor company products. Links to device choice are less well studied.
What can patients ask before receiving an implant?
Patients can ask about the device brand, its track record, other options, the surgeon experience with it, and whether the surgeon has any financial ties to the manufacturer.
Is disclosure of device industry payments required in the EU?
There is no single EU-wide law requiring it, although some countries such as France have their own mandatory transparency rules for health product makers.
Insights, Analysis, and Developments
Editorial Note: The vaginal mesh scandal, in which thousands of women in the UK were left with chronic pain after implants, showed how patients can be harmed when concerns about medical devices are ignored, and it led directly to the 2020 Cumberlege review, First Do No Harm. That review called for a central register of payments from industry to clinicians, a step this study says is still needed. Education funding can support useful training, but when it flows from the same companies whose products are being chosen, it should at least be visible to patients. People facing surgery involving an implant can ask their surgeon why a particular device was chosen and whether they have any financial ties to its maker.*
Attribution/Source(s): This peer-reviewed publication was selected for publishing by the editors of Disabled World (DW) due to its relevance to the disability community. Originally issued as a press release by University of Bath and published on 18 Apr 2024. Last updated on 8 Nov 2026. This content may have been edited for style, clarity, or brevity.
* Editorial additions by Ian C. Langtree.