Driving with Hemianopia - Failure to Detect Pedestrians
Author: Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary : Contact: Mary Leach - Mary_Leach@meei.harvard.edu - Ph. 617-573-4170
Synopsis and Key Points:
Information and reseach results regarding the affect of hemianopia on driving ability and field of vision.
Main DigestA diagnosis of hemianopia, or blindness in one half of the visual field in both eyes as the result of strokes, tumors or trauma often means the end of driving.
Or hemianopsia - A decreased vision or blindness (anopsia) in half the visual field of one or both eyes, usually on one side of the vertical mid-line. The most common causes of this damage are stroke, brain tumor, and trauma. A homonymous hemianopsia is the loss of half of the visual field on the same side in both eyes. A Heteronymous hemianopsia is the loss of half of the visual field on different sides in both eyes. Quadrantanopia (quadrantanopsia/quadrantic hemianopia) is decreased vision or blindness in one quarter of the visual field.
In about half of the states in the United States and in many other countries, driving with hemianopia is prohibited. However, in some countries including Belgium, the Netherlands, the UK, Switzerland and Canada, driving with hemianopia is permitted after passing a specialized road test. Researchers at Massachusetts Eye and Ear/Schepens Eye Research Institute set out to determine the extent to which people with hemianopia can compensate for the lost vision when driving, with a long term goal of developing and evaluating devices and training that will assist them to drive more safely.
People with hemianopia have to look (scan) with eye and/or head movements toward the side of the field loss in order to see obstacles or hazards on that side.
Using a driving simulator, researchers at Massachusetts Eye and Ear/Schepens Eye Research Institute set out to determine the extent to which people with hemianopia can compensate for the lost vision when driving, with a long term goal of developing and evaluating devices and training that will assist them to drive more safely. Photo Credit: Mass. Eye and Ear/Schepens Eye Research Institute
"The wide field of view that needs to be scanned at intersections presents an especially challenging situation for drivers with hemianopia as they have to scan larger angles than drivers with a full field of vision in order to see all of the intersection on the side of the field loss," said lead author Alex Bowers, Ph.D.
Bowers and colleagues used a driving simulator to evaluate head scanning behaviors of 14 drivers with hemianopia and 12 drivers with normal vision as they approached intersections. Their results are described in the March 12 issue of Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science in the paper: Driving with Hemianopia: IV. Head Scanning and Detection at Intersections in a Simulator.
"We found that participants with hemianopia showed compensatory scanning patterns in that their first scan was usually to the side of their field loss. Drivers with right hemianopia tended to look to the right before looking to the left. By comparison, the normally sighted drivers and drivers with left hemianopia typically looked to the left first," Bowers said.
However, the drivers with hemianopia did not compensate by making larger head scans to the side of their field loss, as needed. In fact, their head scans were generally smaller than those of drivers with normal vision. "Yet, you might have expected the opposite as drivers with hemianopia have to scan a long way (close to 90 degrees) in order to see of all of the intersection on the side of their field loss," Bowers said.
Drivers with hemianopia, especially drivers with right hemianopia, had low detection rates for pedestrians that appeared on the side of their field loss.
Analyses of the head scans at these intersections revealed that the detection failures were either because the driver never scanned to the side of their field loss, or because they scanned, but not far enough, Bowers said.
"We might have expected that drivers with hemianopia would have had lower rates of failing to scan than drivers with normal vision, but this wasn't the case," Bowers said.
The findings suggest that, although there is evidence of compensation for the hemifield loss in some aspects of their scanning at intersections, the scanning patterns employed by some drivers with hemianopia may be insufficient for safe driving. Based on these individual responses, some drivers might benefit from training tailored to the specific problem areas identified in the study, Bowers noted.
She went on to summarize, "Our results underscore the importance of individualized evaluations for people with hemianopia who wish to resume driving. While some of the participants in our study frequently did not head scan to the side of their field loss, others always scanned to that side. Individualized assessments are an important component of the special provisions (regulations) that enable drivers with visual field loss to demonstrate their ability to drive safely in specialized road tests in other countries."
This research was supported by National Institutes of Health Grants EY12890 and EY018680. Authors included Alex R. Bowers, Egor Ananyev, Aaron J. Mandel, Robert B. Goldstein and Eli Peli, of Mass. Eye and Ear/Schepens Eye Research Institute and Harvard Medical School.
- 1 - Eye Stye: Cures and Causes of Styes on the Eyelid : Disabled World (2009/07/07)
- 2 - My Eyes Seem to be Getting Worse as I Get Older - Should I See an Eye Doctor : American Academy of Ophthalmology (2014/09/11)
- 3 - Retinitis Pigmentosa: Inherited Eye Diseases : Thomas C. Weiss (2014/07/16)
- 4 - Learning a New Sense by Helping Blind See with Their Fingers : Weizmann Institute of Science (2012/11/05)
- 5 - Discovery of Gene May Provide Treatment for Nearsightedness : Duke University Medical Center (2010/09/12)
- 6 - Gene Responsible for Eye Degeneration and Blindness Discovered : University of Geneva (2018/08/13)
- 7 - What to Expect at an Eye Examination : Wendy Taormina-Weiss (2012/09/24)
• Disabled World is strictly a news and information website provided for general informational purpose only and does not constitute medical advice. Materials presented are in no way meant to be a substitute for professional medical care by a qualified practitioner, nor should they be construed as such. Any 3rd party offering or advertising on disabled-world.com does not constitute endorsement by Disabled World.
• Please report outdated or inaccurate information to us.